Non-Incorporation of the Principle of Non-Refoulement in the Chilean Immigration and Aliens Law

Authors

  • Valentina Rioseco Vallejos School of Law, the University of Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.56784/hrgs.v2i1.51

Keywords:

Chilean migration law, Human rights incorporation, International migration law, Inter-American human rights law, Principle of non-refoulement

Abstract

This paper critically analyses the non-incorporation of the principle of non-refoulement in the Chilean Immigration and Aliens Law 21.325 of 20 April 2021. It was published in the context of migratory pressures within the Latin American region, deriving mainly from the Venezuelan socio-political crisis. It was also published after the recommendations given by the CMW in the last two periodic reviews of 2011 and 2021 to update the previous version dictated during the Pinochet dictatorship. As a state party to the core international human rights treaties and the American Convention on Human Rights, an urgent claim existed in Chile to adapt its migration law. Following a heated debate in 2019, the parliament eliminated the recognition of the principle of non-refoulement contained in the draft law arguing it was already recognised in refugee legislation. Instead, they identified a ‘complementary protection’. This paper examines whether this decision breaches human rights standards, particularly the obligation to adopt legislative measures to give effect to the principle of non-refoulement. It begins by analysing the principle of non-refoulement in international refugee law. Then, it turns into identifying the human rights obligations emanating from the principle of non-refoulement. Finally, the paper applies this standard to law 21.325. The paper concludes that not incorporating the principle of non-refoulement into law 21.325 constitutes a breach of Chile’s human rights obligations, facing the risk of incurring international responsibility.

References

ACNUR. (n.d.). Buena práctica 4: Carácter declarativo de la condición de refugiado. Retrieved 11 April 2023, from https://acnur.org/fileadmin/Documentos/Proteccion/Buenas_Practicas/9280.pdf

Acosta, D. (2018). The National versus the Foreigner in South America: 200 years of migration and citizenship law. Cambridge University Press.

Acosta, D., Blouin, C., & Feline Freier, L. (n.d.). La emigración venezolana: Respuestas latinoamericanas. Retrieved 4 July 2023, from https://www.fundacioncarolina.es/la-emigracion-venezolana-respuestas-latinoamericanas/

Akal, A. B. (2023). Third Country Processing Regimes and the Violation of the Principle of Non-Refoulement: A Case Study of Australia’s Pacific Solution. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 24(1), 231–248. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-022-00948-z

American Convention on Human Rights (Pact of San José, Costa Rica), 1144 UNTS 123 (1978).

Arifin, S. (2022). Abuse of Human Rights in Myanmar: An Urgent Appeal to Reinterpret the ASEAN Non-Interference Principle. Human Rights in the Global South (HRGS), 1(2), 128–144. https://doi.org/10.56784/hrgs.v1i2.12

Behrman, S. (2019). Refugee Law as Means of Control. Journal of Refugee Studies, 32(1), 42–62.

Besson, S. (2011). Sovereignty. In Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law [MPEPIL]. https://opil.ouplaw.com/view/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e1472

Blouin, C., Berganza, I., & Luisa Feline, F. (2020). The spirit of Cartagena? Applying the extended refugee definition to Venezuelans in Latin America - ProQuest. Forced Migration Review, 63, 64–66.

Byrne, R., & Gammeltoft-Hansen, T. (2020). International Refugee Law between Scholarship and Practice. International Journal of Refugee Law, 32(2), 181–199.

CADEM. (2023). Encuesta Plaza Publica. https://cadem.cl/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Track-PP-483-Abril-S2-VF.pdf

Çalı, B., Costello, C., & Cunningham, S. (2020). Hard Protection through Soft Courts? Non-Refoulement before the United Nations Treaty Bodies. German Law Journal, 21(3), 355–384. https://doi.org/10.1017/glj.2020.28

Cámara de Diputados. (2019). Legislatura 366a, sesión 126a. https://www.camara.cl/pdf.aspx?prmID=13491%20&prmTIPO=TEXTOSESION

Cantor, D. J., & Barichello, S. E. (2013). The Inter-American Human Rights System: A New Model for Integrating Refugee and Complementary Protection? International Journal of Human Rights, 17(Issues 5-6), 689–706.

Carreño, A., Cabieses, B., & Urrutia, C. (2019). PMH8 Experiences and Health needs of asylum seekers and refugees of Latin American origin in Chile. Value in Health Regional Issues, 19, S50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vhri.2019.08.289

Cartagena Declaration on Refugees, Colloquium on the International Protection of Refugees in Central America, Mexico and Panama., (1984). https://www.oas.org/dil/1984_cartagena_declaration_on_refugees.pdf

CAT. (2018a). Concluding Observations on the sixth periodic report of Chile. CAT/C/CHL/CO/6.

CAT. (2018b). General Comment No. 4 (2017) on the implementation of article 3 of the Convention in the context of article 22. CAT/C/GC/4.

CAT. (2018c). General Comment No. 4. Implementation of article 3 of the Convention in the context of article 22. CAT/C/GC/4.

Catro Padrón, M., & Feline Freier, L. (2021). ¿Invisibles o invisibilizados? La COVID-19 y los solicitantes de refugio venezolanos en Perú. Revista CIDOB DÁfers Internacionals, 129, 31–55.

CCPR. (1986). General Comment 15: The Position of Aliens Under the Covenant. UN Doc. HRI/GEN/1/Rev.9 (Vol. I).

CCPR. (1992). General Comment No. 20: Article 7 (Prohibition of torture, or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment).

CCPR. (1999). General Comment No 27 (67*) Freedom of Movement (article 12). CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.9.

CCPR. (2004). General Comment No. 31. The Nature of the General Legal Obligation Imposed on States Parties to the Covenant. CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.13.

Communication No. 2007/2010, CCPR/C/110/D/2007/2010 (CCPR 12 May 2014).

Communication No. 2613/2015, CCPR/C/119/D/2613/2015 (CCPR 12 May 2017).

Centro de Prensa. (2023, April 11). Comisión inició el debate de proyecto que tipifica el delito de ingreso clandestino a territorio nacional. Cámara de Diputadas y Diputados. https://www.camara.cl/cms/destacado/2023/04/11/comision-inicio-el-debate-de-proyecto-que-tipifica-el-delito-de-ingreso-clandestino-a-territorio-nacional/

Ceriani Cernadas, P. (2011). Luces y sombras en la legislación migratoria latinoamericana. Nueva Sociedad, 233, 19.

Chetail, V. (2019). International Migration Law. Oxford University Press.

Choy, W. C., & Shi, X. (2021). A comprehensive review of refugee and asylum studies in contemporary Hong Kong: Law, policies, and lived experiences. Asian Journal of Social Science, 49(1), 38–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajss.2020.11.002

Ciliberto, G. (2021). A Brand-New Exclusionary Clause to the Prohibition of Collective Expulsion of Aliens: The Applicant’s Own Conduct in N.D. and D.T. v Spain. Human Rights Law Review, 21, 203–220.

CMW. (2011). Consideration of reports submitted by State parties under article 74 of the Convention. CMW/C/CHL/CO/1.

CMW. (2018). List of issues prior to submission of the second periodic report of Chile. CMW/C/CHL/QPR/2.

CMW. (2020). Conversatorio: Estándares de Derechos Humanos y Migración. Senado de Chile. https://acnudh.org/load/2020/08/Conversatorio-Proyecto-de-Ley-de-Migración-de-Chile-Senado-ABN-y-ECS.pdf

CMW. (2021). Concluding observations on the second periodic report of Chile. CMW/C/CHL/CO/2.

Constitución Política de la República de Chile, (2010).

Convention and Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, § ca (1951). https://www.unhcr.org/3b66c2aa10

Ostos Buitrago Juan contra Subsecretaria del Interior, ROL 37229-2017 (Corte Suprema 22 August 2017).

Sáez con Bellolio, ROL 131056-2020 (Corte Suprema 15 March 2021).

Instituto Nacional de Derechos Humanos con Bellolio, Rol 115.005-2022 (Corte Suprema 20 March 2023).

Costello, C. (2012). Courting Access to Asylum in Europe: Recent Supranational Jurisprudence Explored. Human Rights Law Review, 12(2), 287–339.

Costello, C. (2016). The search for the Outer Edges of Non-refoulement in Europe: Exceptionality and Flagrant Breaches. In B. Burson & D. J. Cantor (Eds.), Human Rights and the Refugee Definition: Comparative Legal Practice and Theory. BRILL. http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ed/detail.action?docID=4540477

Costello, C., & Foster, M. (2016). Non-refoulement as Custom and Jus Cogens? Putting the Prohibition to the Test. In M. den Heijer & H. van der Wilt (Eds.), Netherlands Yearbook of International Law 2015 (Vol. 46, pp. 273–327). T.M.C. Asser Press. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-6265-114-2_10

Costello, C., & Foster, M. (2022). (Some) refugees welcome: When is differentiating between refugees unlawful discrimination? International Journal of Discrimination and the Law, 22(3), 233–280. https://doi.org/10.1177/13582291221116476

Costello, C., & Mann, I. (2020). Border Justice: Migration and Accountability for Human Rights Violations. German Law Journal, 21(3), 311–334. https://doi.org/10.1017/glj.2020.27

Darling, J. (2022). The politics of discretion: Authority and influence in asylum dispersal. Political Geography, 94, 102560-. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2021.102560

Dembour, M.-B. (2015). When humans become migrants: Study of the European Court of Human Rights with an Inter-American counterpoint. (First edition.). University Press.

di Pascale, A. (2015). Exceptional Duties to Admit Aliens. In S. R. Plender (Ed.), Issues in International Migration Law (pp. 201–222). Brill.

Díaz-Sánchez, J. P., Bonilla-Bolaños, A., & Obaco, M. (2021). Where To Go? Drivers of Venezuelan Asylum Seekers. Journal of Refugee Studies, 34(2), 1713–1729. https://doi.org/10.1093/jrs/fez111

Feddersen M., M., Morales M., A., Ramaciotti M., J. P., & Vera E., M. (2023). Ley sobre Protección de Refugiados en Chile. Nudos críticos, desafíos urgentes y alternativas hacia el futuro. Centro de Políticas Migratoria. https://www.politicasmigratorias.org/publicaciones

Feline Freier, L. (2022). COVID-19, Migrant Labor and Inclusion in South America. Global Labour Journal, 13(3), Article 3. https://doi.org/10.15173/glj.v13i3.5304

Feline Freier, L., & Parent, N. (2019). The regional response to the Venezuelan exodus. Current History, 118(805), 56–61.

Fischel de Andrade, J. H. (2019). The 1984 Cartagena Declaration: A Critical Review of Some Aspects of Its Emergence and Relevance. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 38(4), 341–362. https://doi.org/10.1093/rsq/hdz012

Foster, M., Lambert, H., & McAdam, J. (2021). Refugee Protection in the COVID-19 Crisis and beyond: The Capacity and Limits of International Law Thematic Issue: Rights Protection amidst COVID-19. University of New South Wales Law Journal, 44(1), 104–125.

Garrett, R., & Barrett, N. (2021). Dublin III in Practice: Synthesizing a Framework for European Non-Refoulement Cases at the Human Rights Committee. Journal of Human Rights Practice, 13(2), 250–269. https://doi.org/10.1093/jhuman/huab032

Guild, Elspeth. (2014). Protection in the event of removal, expulsion or extradition. In S. Peers, E. Guild, T. Harvey, K. Jeff, & W. Angela (Eds.), The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights A Commentary (pp. 543–562). Bloomsbury Publishing. http://dx.doi.org/10.5040/9781849468350.ch-022

Hammoud-Gallego, O. (2022). A Liberal Region in a World of Closed Borders? The Liberalization of Asylum Policies in Latin America, 1990–2020. International Migration Review, 56(1), 63–96. https://doi.org/10.1177/01979183211026202

Hammoud-Gallego, O., & Freier, L. F. (2023). Symbolic Refugee Protection: Explaining Latin America’s Liberal Refugee Laws. American Political Science Review, 117(2), 454–473. https://doi.org/10.1017/S000305542200082X

Hathaway, J. (2005). The rights of refugees under international law. Cambridge University Press.

Hathaway, J. (2018). The Global Cop-Out on Refugees. International Journal of Refugee Law, 30(4), 591–604.

Henriquez-Viñas, M. (2022). La Corte Suprema Chilena y la protección de la libertad personal de los migrantes: Un estudio jurisprudencial. Jurídicas, 19(21), 263–277. https://doi.org/10.17151/jurid.2022.19.1.15

IACHR. (n.d.). Informe sobre la situación de los derechos humanos solicitantes de asilo en el marco del sistema canadiense de determinación de la condición de refugiado. Retrieved 28 February 2019, from http://www.cidh.org/countryrep/Canada2000sp/canada.htm#A.%C2%A0%C2%A0%C2%A0 Visi%C3%B3n General del Proceso de Petici%C3%B3n y Determinaci%C3%B3n

IACHR. (2015). Human Mobility. Inter-American Standards. OEA/Ser.L/V/II.Doc.46/15. http://www.oas.org/en/iachr/reports/pdfs/HumanMobility.pdf

IACHR. (2019). Interamerican Principles on the Human Rights of all migrants, refugees, stateless persons and victims of human trafficking. https://www.oas.org/en/iachr/decisions/pdf/Resolution-4-19-en.pdf

Case of the Pacheco Tineo Family v. Bolivia. Preliminary Objections, Merits, Reparation and Costs. Judgment, (IACtHR 25 November 2013).

Rights and Guarantees of Children in the Context of Migration and/or in need of International Protection. Advisory Opinion OC-21/14, (IACtHR, 19 August 2014).

Case of Wong Ho Wing V. Peru. Judgement (Preliminary objection, merits, reparation and costs), (IACtHR 30 June 2015).

INE. (2022, October 12). Demografía. INE. https://www.ine.gob.cl/estadisticas/sociales/demografia-y-vitales/demografia-y-migracion/2022/10/12/población-extranjera-residente-en-chile-llegó-a-1.482.390-personas-en-2021-un-1-5-más-que-en-2020#:~:text=Noticias%20Relacionadas-,Población%20extranjera%20residente%20en%20Chile%20llegó%20a%201.482.390%20personas,5%25%20más%20que%20en%202020&text=Según%20estimaciones%20al%2031%20de,%2C%20Haití%2C%20Colombia%20y%20Bolivia.

Janmyr, M. (2021). The 1951 Refugee Convention and Non-Signatory States: Charting a Research Agenda. International Journal of Refugee Law, 33(2), 188–213. https://doi.org/10.1093/ijrl/eeab043

Jelić, I., & Mührel, L. (2022). The Human Rights Committee—Challenges and Prospects for Enhanced Effectiveness and Integration. Journal of Human Rights Practice, 14(1), 17–43. https://doi.org/10.1093/jhuman/huac026

Lohaus, M., & Stapel, S. (2022). Who commits to regional human rights treaties? Reputational benefits, sovereignty costs, regional dynamics. Journal of Human Rights. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/epdf/10.1080/14754835.2022.2135369?needAccess=true&role=button

M A Hamad, A., Jannial, J., & Indriyani, R. (2022). Mechanisms of the Legal Protection of Human Rights in Global Regulation. Human Rights in the Global South (HRGS), 1(2), 145–157. https://doi.org/10.56784/hrgs.v1i2.31

Magwood, O., Bellai-Dussault, K., Fox, G., McCutcheon, C., Adams, O., Saad, A., & Kassam, A. (2023). Diagnostic test accuracy of screening tools for post-traumatic stress disorder among refugees and asylum seekers: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Migration and Health, 7, 100144. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmh.2022.100144

Mann, I. (2020). The Right to Perform Rescue at Sea: Jurisprudence and Drowning. German Law Journal, 21(3), 598–619. https://doi.org/10.1017/glj.2020.30

Mathew, P. (2021). Non-refoulement. In C. Costello, M. Foster, & J. McAdam (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of International Refugee Law (p. 0). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/law/9780198848639.003.0051

McAdam, J. (2020). Protecting People Displaced by the Impacts of Climate Change: The UN Human Rights Committee and Principle of Non-Refoulement. Cambridge University Press, 114(4), 708–725.

McCall-Smith, K. (2020). Treaty bodies and states: Shaping custom. In S. Droubi & J. d’Aspremont (Eds.), International Organizations, Non-State Actors, and The Formation of Customary International Law. Mellan Schill Perspectives on International Law (pp. 321–342). Manchester University Press. https://www.research.ed.ac.uk/en/publications/treaty-bodies-and-states-shaping-custom

Ministerio del Interior y Seguridad Pública. (2022). Conoce sobre el Proceso de Formulación de la Política de Migración. Ministerio Del Interior y Seguridad Pública. https://www.interior.gob.cl/sin-categoria/2022/06/14/conoce-sobre-el-proceso-de-formulacion-de-la-politica-de-migracion/

Muktiono. (2022). Indonesian Blasphemy Law as Legal Forum for Renegotiating Indonesian Secularity. Human Rights in the Global South (HRGS), 1(1), 48–69. https://doi.org/10.56784/hrgs.v1i1.1

Ley 20.430 que establece disposiciones sobre protección de refugiados, (2010).

Ley 21.325 de Migración y Extranjeria, (2021).

Nagy, E., Herpertz, S. C., Schohl, K., Zehetmair, C., Gebhardt, N., Friederich, H.-C., & Nikendei, C. (2023). The refugee and asylum seeker mental health treatment screener (RAS-MT-screener): Feasibility and psychometric properties of a questionnaire detecting refugees’ and asylum seekers’ need and urgency for mental health treatment. General Hospital Psychiatry, 83, 43–50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2023.03.011

Ochoa, J. (2020). South America’s Response to the Venezuelan Exodus: A Spirit of Regional Cooperation? International Journal of Refugee Law, 32(3), 472–497. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1093/ijrl/eeaa033

Ogg, K., & Taoi, C. (2021). COVID-19 Border Closures: A Violation of Non-Refoulement Obligations in International Refugee and Human Rights Law? The Australian Year Book of International Law Online, 39(1), 32–48. https://doi.org/10.1163/26660229-03901004

Olea, H. (2012). Refugiados en Chile: Análisis de la Ley 20.430 y su reglamento. Centro de Derechos Humanos UDP. https://derechoshumanos.udp.cl/publicacion/refugiados-en-chile-analisis-de-la-ley-20-430-y-su-reglamento/

Pirovino, S., & Papyrakis, E. (2023). Understanding the global patterns of Venezuelan migration: Determinants of an expanding diaspora. Development Studies Research, 10(2). https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/epdf/10.1080/21665095.2022.2147561?needAccess=true&role=button

Pratiwi, C. S., Listiningrum, P., & Al Anwary, M. A. Z. (2022). Critiques on Contemporary Discourse of International Human Rights Law: a Global South Perspective. Human Rights in the Global South (HRGS), 1(1), 1–12. https://doi.org/10.56784/hrgs.v1i1.3

Reches, D. (2022). Complying with international and regional law during the pandemic—Asylum seekers and COVID-19 emergency measures in EU Member States Germany and Greece. Social Sciences & Humanities Open, 6(1), 100370. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2022.100370

Shaindl, K., & Lazickas, S. (2022). Non-refoulement: A human rights perspective on environmental migration from small island developing states. Journal of International Affairs, 74(2), 21–14.

Staberock, Gerald. (2011). Human Rights, Domestic Implementation. In Max Planck Ecyclopedia of Public International Law. Oxford University Press. http://opil.ouplaw.com/view/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e1734

Tekin, B. Ç. (2022). Bordering through othering: On strategic ambiguity in the making of the EU-Turkey refugee deal. Political Geography, 98, 102735. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2022.102735

UN CMW. (2013). General comment No. 2 on the rights of migrant workers in an irregular situation and members of their families. CMW/C/CG/2.

UN HRC. (2018a). Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. A/HRC/37/50.

UN HRC. (2018b). Report on the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants (A/HRC/38/41).

UNCCT. (2021). Human Rights at International Borders. A trainer’s Guide. UN. https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Publications/HR_InternationalBorders.pdf

UNGA. (2022). Report of the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants. A/77/189.

UNHCR. (1991). Conclusions adopted by the executive committee on the international protection of refugeess. (Conclusion No. 65). https://www.unhcr.org/en-my/578371524.pdf

UNHCR. (2015). Memorias del Trigésimo Aniversario de la Declaración de Cartagena sobre los Refugiados. https://www.refworld.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/rwmain/opendocpdf.pdf?reldoc=y&docid=568cf8f64

UNHCR. (2016). The Refugee Situation in Latin America: Protection and Solutions Based on the Pragmatic Approach of the Cartagena Declaration on Refugees of 1984. International Journal of Refugee Law, 18(1), 252–270.

UNHCR. (2019). Handbook on procedures and criteria for determining refugee status and guidelines on international protection. https://www.unhcr.org/publications/legal/5ddfcdc47/handbook-procedures-criteria-determining-refugee-status-under-1951-convention.html

Vallejos, L., & Silva, M. (2023). Ejecución del ‘criterio Valencia’: Los primeros resultados de las peticiones de prisión preventiva. EMOL. https://www.emol.com/noticias/Nacional/2023/04/12/1091957/criterio-valencia-prision-preventiva-extranjero.html

Watters, C., Mowlds, W., O’Connor, A., & M Sarma, K. (2022). ‘The Last Arrival Point’: The refugee experience of resettlement in Ireland. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 88, 66–76. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijintrel.2022.03.009

Downloads

Published

2023-07-31

Issue

Section

Articles

Citation Check